Few love triangles have divided fans quite like The Summer I Turned Pretty. Adapted from Jenny Han’s beloved novels, the series brings to life the emotional tension between Belly Conklin and Team Conrad or Team Jeremiah the Fisher brothers — Conrad and Jeremiah. Each season only fuels the debate: are you Team Conrad or Team Jeremiah?
Both brothers offer something different — two sides of love that reflect passion and comfort, mystery and openness. But what makes this rivalry so captivating is how deeply it connects to the experience of growing up, choosing love, and learning about yourself along the way.
Team Conrad: The Pull of First Love
Conrad Fisher represents the quiet, brooding allure of first love. He’s complex, guarded, and impossibly magnetic. Beneath his calm exterior lies a storm of emotion — love he doesn’t quite know how to express.
For Belly, Conrad is the one who makes her heart race and her world shift. Their chemistry is undeniable, but so is their emotional chaos. Loving Conrad means accepting uncertainty and heartbreak, and that’s what makes their connection so unforgettable.
Fans of Team Conrad see him as the more “real” love — flawed, intense, and raw. It’s the kind of bond that changes you forever, even when it hurts.
Team Jeremiah: The Warmth of Steady Love
Jeremiah Fisher, on the other hand, is sunshine in human form. He’s open, affectionate, and unafraid to wear his heart on his sleeve. With Jeremiah, Belly feels seen, appreciated, and loved without games or hesitation.
Where Conrad brings tension, Jeremiah brings tenderness. He represents a love that feels safe — one built on friendship, laughter, and mutual respect.
Team Jeremiah fans champion him for being emotionally available and mature. He communicates, he listens, and he loves without restraint — qualities that make him an ideal partner for Belly’s growing heart.
Belly Conklin: The Heart Torn Between Two Loves
At the center of the storm is Belly Conklin — no longer the little girl who spent summers at Cousins Beach, but a young woman discovering who she is and what love means.
Conrad challenges her to feel deeply, while Jeremiah reminds her what joy and stability feel like. Her journey isn’t just about romance — it’s about identity, maturity, and learning what she deserves.
Belly’s choice reflects not just who she loves more, but who she is at each stage of her life. In many ways, both Fisher brothers help shape the woman she becomes.
Why Fans Are Still Divided
Part of what makes The Summer I Turned Pretty so enduring is its emotional honesty. It doesn’t present love as easy or perfect — it’s messy, emotional, and shaped by timing.
Some fans crave the burning tension of Team Conrad, while others find comfort in the steady glow of Team Jeremiah.
That’s why the fandom conversation continues to thrive — because both sides are right in their own way. The series beautifully shows that love doesn’t always have one answer; sometimes, it simply mirrors who you are in that moment.
FAQ
1. Why are fans split between Team Conrad and Team Jeremiah?
Because each brother represents a different kind of love — Conrad’s deep, complicated passion versus Jeremiah’s open, steady warmth.
2. Who is better for Belly in the long run?
That depends on what kind of love she’s ready for. Conrad challenges her to read more here yeema movies grow; Jeremiah helps her feel safe and understood.
3. Does Belly end up with Conrad or Jeremiah?
Without spoiling too much — the story’s resolution evolves across books and seasons, reflecting Belly’s emotional growth and what she truly values in love.
